Super Lawyers
Avvo Badge
Super Lawyers - Rising Stars 2018

Florida Personal Guaranty Defense Attorney

A personal guaranty can expose an individual to a business debt even when a company owns the property or signed the loan. The first question is what that individual actually promised. The answer may depend on the guaranty’s limits, conditions, waivers, later amendments, and the particular default alleged.

Attorney Andrew J. Pascale represents clients in Florida commercial loan and guaranty disputes. An initial review separates the lender’s claim against the borrower, its rights against collateral, and its claim against each guarantor. Those claims may arise from the same transaction without presenting identical issues.

Start with the signed obligation

The word “guarantor” on a demand letter is a starting point for investigation. Obtain the executed guaranty and identify the parties, the debt covered, and the capacity in which each person signed. Then compare that agreement with the note, mortgage, credit agreement, and later modifications.

Look for a dollar cap or percentage limitation, a provision covering future advances, an expiration or termination mechanism, and language addressing interest, collection costs, and attorney’s fees. Determine whether the claim depends on a specified event or alleged conduct. A limited guaranty and an agreement described as unconditional can require very different analysis.

Florida’s statute of frauds, section 725.01, generally requires a signed writing for a promise to answer for another person’s debt. Whether that provision or an exception applies requires examination of the particular agreement and claim. It does not replace a review of the complete transaction.

A defense must fit the language and the evidence

Potential issues include whether the lender is enforcing the correct agreement, whether the claimed obligation falls within its scope, whether required conditions were met, and whether the amount demanded credits payments and other recoveries correctly. A defense should identify the disputed provision or transaction and the records supporting the position.

Loan changes deserve close attention. Did a modification extend maturity, increase the obligation, change the collateral, or release another party? Did the guarantor consent in the modification or in advance through the original agreement? A change to the borrower’s loan does not automatically release a guarantor. Consent and waiver language must be read before drawing that conclusion.

Our article on guarantor defenses in commercial foreclosures provides additional background. The available defenses in a particular case must be evaluated against the signed documents and applicable law.

Reconcile the demand before evaluating a settlement

Separate principal, interest, default interest, expenses, fees, and credits. Identify what the guaranty covers and how any limitation operates. Ask for the records supporting disputed entries rather than treating a payoff total as a complete explanation.

A collateral sale, borrower payment, or payment by another obligor can raise questions about how the remaining demand was calculated. The timing and legal effect of a credit require review. Likewise, the value attributed to collateral should not simply be assumed to extinguish a personal obligation.

When real estate is involved, coordinate this review with the commercial foreclosure defense. A proposed resolution of the property claim should address what happens to the guaranty claim as well.

Written workout terms should address personal exposure

A sale, refinance, surrender, or payment arrangement may resolve an immediate property problem while leaving other obligations contested. Before agreeing to a workout, identify who receives a release, which agreements it covers, whether the release is conditional, and what happens if the contemplated transaction does not close.

Florida’s credit-agreement statute, section 687.0304, imposes writing requirements for a debtor maintaining an action on a credit agreement. It also addresses claims that a lender agreed to forbear or extend installments. The statute’s application should be considered when evaluating alleged oral workout promises; the label placed on a claim does not answer the issue.

Hypothetical example: A company agrees to sell its building and apply the proceeds to its loan. Its owner expects the sale to end the dispute because the owner signed only as a guarantor. The settlement review should separately address the sale proceeds, any remaining debt, the guaranty, and dismissal of the pending claims. A closing instruction directing payment to the lender is not the same document as a release of the owner.

Questions to organize before a consultation

  • Who signed the guaranty, and is the complete executed version available?
  • Which debt and default does the lender identify?
  • What limitations, conditions, consents, and waivers appear in the agreement?
  • Were the loan or collateral arrangements changed after signing?
  • Which payments, sale proceeds, or other recoveries should be reconciled?
  • What outcome is needed: contesting liability, correcting the amount, retaining property, completing a sale, or resolving personal exposure?

Bring the summons and complaint, the guaranty and loan documents, amendments, demand letters, payment records, and settlement correspondence. Identify hearing dates and deadlines when requesting the consultation. Negotiations should not be treated as a change to a court deadline without a valid basis.

Discuss a Florida personal guaranty claim

Call (877) 667-1211 to discuss the claim and whether representation may be appropriate. Initial contact should identify the parties and approaching deadlines before confidential documents are provided.

For related issues, see our discussions of promissory notes, deficiency judgments, and business litigation.

Client Reviews

I contacted Andrew for assistance with the selling of my business. He was very knowledgeable and explained the process to me during the selling of my shop. The documentation was produced very quickly and accurately which made both parties very comfortable with the process. I would highly recommend...

K.A.

Andrew Pascale was assigned to my cases about 6 years prior. The magnificent work he completed through the years was amazing. He is very detailed and direct with important matters. I felt comfortable with my cases being handled by him. He kept me informed of the status and just what was going on. I...

L.R.

We were having problems with collections in our business. Andy stepped up quickly to take over the process from our last attorney.

J.L.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Contact Us Now
  2. 2 Over a Decade of Experience
  3. 3 Speak With an Attorney Directly
Fill out the contact form or call us at (877) 667-1211 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message