Florida Trust Litigation Attorney

A trust dispute often starts with an unanswered question: Where did the money go? Why has a distribution stopped? Which version of the trust controls? Why is an asset being treated as someone’s individual property?

Answering those questions requires attention to the trust documents, the ownership of the assets, and the records of administration. Attorney Andrew J. Pascale represents trustees and beneficiaries in Florida trust disputes involving accountings, fiduciary conduct, contested documents, and substantial property interests.

Identify what is actually in dispute

Several disagreements can exist within the same family without presenting the same legal issue. A challenge to the validity of a trust amendment differs from a claim that a trustee mismanaged an otherwise valid trust. A dispute about the meaning of a distribution provision differs from a dispute about whether the trust owns a particular account.

That distinction shapes the evidence and the relief to consider. Before treating every disagreement as a demand to remove the trustee, the review should identify the disputed act, the document or duty involved, and the result the client needs.

When the records do not explain the administration

A beneficiary may have received a balance sheet and still be unable to understand a substantial withdrawal, a property transfer, or a payment to someone connected with the trustee. The first question is what information the beneficiary is legally entitled to receive. The next is whether the records supplied actually explain the transaction at issue.

A focused review can compare the trust’s terms with accountings, bank and brokerage records, deeds, distribution records, and correspondence. A transaction timeline can help distinguish an undocumented concern from an identifiable transfer that requires explanation.

Trustee defense starts with the decision and its supporting record

A trustee facing allegations needs a clear account of what was done, why it was done, and how the decision relates to the trust’s terms and applicable duties. The analysis should address the circumstances at the time of the decision, the records supporting it, and the particular breach alleged.

Disputes over discretionary distributions, expenses, investments, or property sales cannot be evaluated solely by whether a beneficiary dislikes the outcome. The governing language, relevant duties, and evidence need to be examined together.

Determine whether the dispute concerns ownership, administration, or validity

Hypothetical example: A family believes a brokerage account belongs to a trust because the account owner referred to it that way. The account registration, transfer documents, and trust instruments may raise a different ownership question. Resolving ownership may be necessary before deciding who was entitled to administer or receive the funds.

A contested amendment presents another kind of inquiry. The execution circumstances, document history, witnesses, communications, and evidence relevant to capacity or influence may be central. Suspicion should be tested against an organized evidentiary record.

Match the requested relief to the problem

The objective may be to obtain information, resolve disputed language, protect an asset, address a particular transaction, or seek a change in administration. The available remedies and their requirements depend on the claim and applicable law. A useful strategy identifies both the alleged wrong and how the proposed relief would correct it.

Cost matters as well. The value of the property, the strength of the evidence, the urgency of the problem, and the effect of continued conflict on administration should inform decisions about negotiation and litigation.

Florida trustee information and removal provisions

Section 736.0813 addresses information and accounting duties to qualified beneficiaries. It generally requires annual accountings for an irrevocable trust, with statutory qualifications and exceptions. While a trust is revocable, the duties under this section extend only to the settlor. Whether a particular person is entitled to particular records requires review of the trust and the applicable provisions.

Section 736.0706 provides grounds for judicial removal of a trustee, including a serious breach of trust, substantially impaired administration caused by lack of cooperation among cotrustees, and specified circumstances involving ineffective administration or changed circumstances. Removal depends on the statutory requirements and evidence; it should be evaluated alongside other relief that could protect the property or resolve the dispute.

Bring notices and accountings to counsel promptly

Do not set aside an accounting or limitation notice while waiting for a family disagreement to resolve. Documents concerning trust administration can have consequences for the time available to assert a claim. The document, when it was received, what it disclosed, and the nature of the proposed claim all require review under section 736.1008 and other applicable law.

For an initial consultation, gather the trust and amendments available to you, relevant notices and accountings, correspondence, and records identifying the disputed assets or transactions. Note any hearing dates or deadlines already communicated to you.

Discuss a trust dispute

Call (877) 667-1211 to discuss the nature of the dispute and whether representation may be appropriate. Identify the relevant parties and any approaching deadlines before providing confidential records.

Related resources: probate litigation, undue influence, and will contests.

Client Reviews

I contacted Andrew for assistance with the selling of my business. He was very knowledgeable and explained the process to me during the selling of my shop. The documentation was produced very quickly and accurately which made both parties very comfortable with the process. I would highly recommend...

K.A.

Andrew Pascale was assigned to my cases about 6 years prior. The magnificent work he completed through the years was amazing. He is very detailed and direct with important matters. I felt comfortable with my cases being handled by him. He kept me informed of the status and just what was going on. I...

L.R.

We were having problems with collections in our business. Andy stepped up quickly to take over the process from our last attorney.

J.L.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Contact Us Now
  2. 2 Over a Decade of Experience
  3. 3 Speak With an Attorney Directly
Fill out the contact form or call us at (877) 667-1211 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message